by Willard Gaylin
Review by S. V. Swamy on Apr 12th 2004
Hatred by Willard Gaylin, M.D. is a good introduction
to understand the dynamics of hatred. Gaylin, a psychiatrist differentiates
hatred from other emotions such as anger, rage, depression, frustration etc.
He brings out that hatred is a disease of the
mind. But he differentiates it from insanity and argues that a person who has
committed a crime out of hatred should not be allowed to go free on the ground
that he is no longer capable of controlling his actions. This argument lacks
conviction and clarity to a lay person.
Gaylin uses mainly two examples in his readable analysis
of crimes of hatred, the holocaust of 1935 and the September 9/11 attack on WTC
by Al Qaeda. He suggests that anti-Semitism is at the back of most hate crimes.
He rightly suggests that fundamentalism is
responsible for creating a horde of fanatics, who are ready to wage a battle
against the enemy, those who don't subscribe to their ideology, and thus the
While most of his analysis is quite lucid and informative,
his argument that hatred must be dealt by normal, legal methods doesn't appeal.
As rightly pointed out by him, both hatred and love are two sides of a coin and
neither can be separated. So as long as love exists, hatred also is bound to
exist. And as long as hero worship is possible, the battle against the devil,
Satan also is possible. The same ordinary man on the street can be roused, can
be hypnotized to go either way. The pendulum can swing in either direction.
The book is useful to an ordinary educated lay
reader as a way to better understand many of the problems of human psyche. But
understanding a problem doesn't always result in its solution. The author has
not really offered a workable solution to the problem of organized hatred.
© 2004 S. V. Swamy
S. V. Swamy, India.